AgentComparison
Cognition AI, Inc. · product · coding agent (editor and cloud agents)

Windsurf

Cognition's agentic coding editor with frontier models and Devin Cloud agents. Free tier; Pro $20/mo - paid tiers can opt out of training.

Group: Coding agents

Windsurf is Cognition's agentic coding editor: Tab completions, inline edits and agent coding in the IDE, with frontier models (OpenAI, Claude, Gemini), Cognition's own SWE 1.7, and Devin Cloud agents on paid plans.

Documentation researched, not testedChecked 25 October 2026Vendor documentation, not a test

The decision in plain English

The Free tier is genuinely usable for light agent coding, but note the data trade: Cognition's platform terms say customer data may be used for model training unless you opt out - and only paid tiers can opt out, which then enables zero data retention with model providers. Pro at $20/month is the tier where privacy control starts.

Best fit

Developers who want an agentic IDE with frontier-model choice and are comfortable opting out of training on a paid tier.

Poor fit

Anyone needing training-free use on a free plan, or a self-hosted editor.

Documented capabilities

Vendor statements, not verified task outcomes.

  • Agentic coding in the IDE with Tab completions and inline edits Source · checked 2026-10-25
  • Frontier model access (OpenAI, Claude, Gemini) plus SWE 1.7 and open-source models Source · checked 2026-10-25
  • Devin Cloud agents (Pro and above) and Devin Desktop (Team full seats) Source · checked 2026-10-25

Permissions and human control

  • Cloud agents act in the vendor environment; editor runs locally with vendor model calls.
  • On opt-out (paid tiers): customer data is not used for any other purpose including training, and zero data retention is enabled with model providers; ZDR does not block abuse-flag retention, safety review or legal process (terms 3.3).
  • Outputs are assigned to the customer (terms 3.1).

Documented controls do not prove that an agent always follows them.

Limits and open questions

  • Free-tier customer data may be used for model training; the opt-out (with zero data retention) requires a paid tier, and on Teams only an admin can exercise it (platform terms, 30 June 2026).
  • Editor quality and agent reliability were not tested.
  • windsurf.com/terms-of-service renders no readable content; the operative terms are Cognition's platform terms, read on cognition.com.

Privacy and security

Cognition privacy policy (updated 9 March 2026) covers Devin and Windsurf: it permits using User Content to train, fine-tune and improve models 'depending on the terms that apply'. The operative split is in the platform terms (updated 30 June 2026): customer data may be used for model training by default; paid-tier customers may opt out, after which data is not used for training and zero data retention applies with model providers (Teams: admin-only opt-out). ZDR exceptions: abuse classifiers, safety/security review, legal process. Outputs are assigned to the customer. Retention otherwise 'as needed', deletion on request. Checked 25 October 2026.

Feature-by-feature: what is documented and what is not

Official sources checked 25 October 2026. A documented feature is a vendor statement, not proof of success.

FeatureEvidence statusDetail and limit
Editor and agentsDocumentedAgentic IDE with Tab and inline edits; Devin Cloud agents on Pro and above. Source
CostPublishedFree $0; Pro $20/month; Max $200/month; Team $80/month + $40 per full dev seat; extra usage at API pricing. Source
Training usePlan-dependentCustomer data may train models by default; paid-tier opt-out stops training and enables ZDR with providers (Teams: admin-only). Source
Output ownershipDocumentedOutputs assigned to the customer. Source

How to start with Windsurf narrowly

  1. Download the Windsurf editor or sign in on the web; the Free tier needs no card.
  2. On any paid tier, exercise the training opt-out (Teams: admin) if you want zero data retention with model providers.

Official product/setup source. These are documentation-based steps, not a hands-on setup test.

Common questions about Windsurf

What is Windsurf for?

Developers who want an agentic IDE with frontier-model choice and are comfortable opting out of training on a paid tier. The vendor describes it as: Windsurf is Cognition's agentic coding editor: Tab completions, inline edits and agent coding in the IDE, with frontier models (OpenAI, Claude, Gemini), Cognition's own SWE 1.7, and Devin Cloud agents on paid plans.

Who should look elsewhere?

Anyone needing training-free use on a free plan, or a self-hosted editor.

How much does Windsurf cost?

windsurf.com/pricing (read 25 October 2026): Free $0; Pro $20/month; Max $200/month; Teams $80/month team plan + $40/month per full dev seat; Enterprise custom.

What can it access and what needs my approval?

Cloud agents act in the vendor environment; editor runs locally with vendor model calls. On opt-out (paid tiers): customer data is not used for any other purpose including training, and zero data retention is enabled with model providers; ZDR does not block abuse-flag retention, safety review or legal process (terms 3.3). Outputs are assigned to the customer (terms 3.1).

What happens to my data?

Cognition privacy policy (updated 9 March 2026) covers Devin and Windsurf: it permits using User Content to train, fine-tune and improve models 'depending on the terms that apply'. The operative split is in the platform terms (updated 30 June 2026): customer data may be used for model training by default; paid-tier customers may opt out, after which data is not used for training and zero data retention applies with model providers (Teams: admin-only opt-out). ZDR exceptions: abuse classifiers, safety/security review, legal process. Outputs are assigned to the customer. Retention otherwise 'as needed', deletion on request. Checked 25 October 2026.

Has AgentComparison tested it?

No. This record is built from the vendor's own documentation, checked 2026-10-25. Vendor claims are attributed, not confirmed.

How to evaluate Windsurf yourself

  1. Pick one low-risk task that matches its documented capabilities: agentic coding in the ide with tab completions and inline edits.
  2. Write the expected output and what counts as failure before you start.
  3. Connect the minimum access needed, and check approval settings first.
  4. Run it twice and compare, then review every action it took.
  5. Check cost after any free allowance. Unknown price is not free.

Related

Documented use cases: Software development and repository work.

Sources and history

Change history

Documentation overview expanded with current pricing/access sources. No hands-on results claimed.

Report a correction