AgentComparison
For retailers, not a leaderboard

AI shopping agents: compare the checkout, not the hype.

Seven agents. Different checkouts. Compare payment, approval and retailer responsibility before deciding what to support.

Short answer: there is no single best shopping agent for every retailer. Copilot Checkout documents an in-chat merchant route; Muse supports both Link and saved merchant cards; dots documents saved-card purchases; Instinct and Grok Bot have confirmed Link support. Spark works through connected apps, while Cue's wallet mechanics remain unclear. Do not treat these as seven identical shopping services.

Documentation checked 9 October 2026. No agents were tested, no purchases made, and no conversion or reliability ranking is claimed. Unknown does not mean unavailable or free.

Product or vendor marks identify the entries; they do not imply endorsement. OpenAI, Gemini, Manus and xAI marks represent their product families where a separate agent mark was not established.

Seven agents, four questions retailers should ask

Seven shopping-related agents and checkout products. Primary sources checked 9 October 2026; no hands-on purchase tests.
Agent / typePurchase routeApproval and retailer responsibilityAccess, cost and limits
Muse
Personal buyer
Link or a saved merchant card
Read detail
Link checkout, or merchant login with a saved card. Link can use a wallet payment at participating businesses or a purchase-scoped virtual card elsewhere.
Approval before every purchase
Read detail
Meta says approval before every purchase. Merchant fulfils the order; supported location, merchant and checkout matter.
US Link documented; wider access varies
Detail and sources
US Link integration documented. Full current markets and retailer-specific charges not verified. Source Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026
Instinct
Personal buyer
Link agent payments
Read detail
Stripe lists Instinct as supporting Link agent payments. Link documents purchase-scoped credentials; this is not proof of a special retailer feed or universal checkout access.
Approve the amount in Link
Read detail
Link documents amount approval before purchases. Instinct terms place the purchase and merchant terms with the customer, not Instinct as seller.
Markets and merchant commissions not verified
Detail and sources
Link support confirmed; complete markets, merchant onboarding and commission schedule not established. Source Source Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026
OpenAI dots
Personal / work assistant
Card saved on merchant site
Read detail
Can buy using a card already saved on the merchant website. A logged-in browser session is documented; not the same product as ChatGPT Instant Checkout.
Approval, including specifically scoped advance approval
Read detail
Purchase approval is required, but may be given in advance when it specifically covers that purchase. Money transfers require takeover.
Retailer account and saved card needed
Detail and sources
Merchant account/card needed for this route. Standalone price, complete markets and a retailer integration programme not verified. Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026
Gemini Spark
Personal agent
Partner apps, including Instacart
Read detail
Google documents connected apps including Instacart for groceries. A partner-app action is not evidence of open checkout on every retailer site.
Designed to ask before spending
Read detail
Google says it is designed to ask before high-stakes actions such as spending. Current help warns scheduled tasks can make unintended actions and may need supervision.
Pro/Ultra; unavailable in UK and other listed markets
Detail and sources
Current help: personal account, age 18+, AI Pro or Ultra, Keep Activity on; excludes UK, EEA, Switzerland and Nigeria. A universal merchant fee or payment rail not verified. Source Source Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026
Cue by Manus
Personal team of agents
Agent has its own wallet
Read detail
Manus documents separate agent identities, including a wallet, email, phone and computer. It does not specify the wallet payment rail in the source checked.
Spend limits and approval rules unknown
Read detail
Wallet spending caps and purchase-approval mechanics not verified. A statement that the user makes the final call is not a documented per-purchase control.
Invitation code; payment rail and price unknown
Detail and sources
Invitation code required. Cue-specific price, merchant charges and supported checkout/account-matching route unknown. Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026
Grok Bot
General-purpose agent
Link agent payments
Read detail
Stripe and Link confirm agent-payment support for Grok Bot. Link provides approved spending credentials; xAI documents a persistent computer and connected work tools.
Approve the amount in Link
Read detail
Link says the user approves the amount before purchases. Do not assume planned autonomous budget controls are available in this integration.
Shopping markets and merchant fees not verified
Detail and sources
Link support documented. Complete shopping markets, retailer programme and merchant commission not verified. Source Source Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026
Microsoft Copilot Checkout
In-chat checkout, not a delegated personal buyer
Embedded checkout inside Copilot
Read detail
Supported products can be bought inside Copilot. Stripe documents ACP and a Shared Payment Token passed to the seller after buyer payment details are provided.
Buyer completes checkout; retailer is merchant of record
Read detail
The buyer completes the checkout. Microsoft and Stripe say the retailer remains merchant of record and controls the customer relationship/data.
US rollout; retailer onboarding routes documented
Detail and sources
US rollout documented. PayPal/Stripe merchant applications; Shopify automatic enrolment after opt-out window, managed in Shopify admin. Universal Copilot-specific merchant fee not verified. Source Source
Last verified: 9 October 2026

What changes at the checkout?

Link support does not mean every order uses a new card

Stripe describes two Muse routes: an existing Link payment method at businesses that accept Link, and a single-use virtual card scoped to an approved purchase elsewhere. Meta also documents purchases with a card saved in the merchant account. A blanket claim that every Muse order uses a new virtual card would be wrong. Stripe payment detail; Meta payment help.

Link lists Muse, Instinct and Grok Bot as supporting agent payments. Its feature matrix does not mark those three as supporting Link financial insights, even though Stripe now offers that capability to agent builders. Do not turn a platform announcement into a live feature claim for every agent. Current supported-feature matrix; Stripe update.

Saved-card purchases are different from embedded commerce

Dots can use a card saved on a merchant website, with approval that can be scoped in advance. Copilot Checkout instead embeds checkout in the chat for supported products. Stripe sends a Shared Payment Token to the seller, who remains merchant of record. Neither fact guarantees account matching, loyalty points or returns reconciliation in your own store. Test those separately. Dots approval rules; Copilot payment flow.

A wallet is not a published spending policy

Cue has an agent wallet according to Manus. We did not establish its payment provider, spend caps or per-purchase approval rules. The Google Spark announcement describes asking before spending, but a general AP2 protocol announcement would not prove that every Spark partner checkout uses that protocol. Those gaps stay visible rather than being filled from a competitor table. Cue documentation; Spark announcement.

Shopify WebMCP is a checkout interface, not universal permission

Shopify documents browser tools to read and update an active checkout and submit it after buyer confirmation. The buyer handles interactions such as Shop Pay login, 3D Secure or blocking extensions. The tools use the checkout UI state and do not require merchant configuration. This supports a browser-agent journey, not a promise that every agent or every checkout works. Checkout WebMCP docs.

Shopify calls these eligible checkouts. If checkout tools are not available, its storefront docs tell the agent to hand the buyer over to the page. Browser WebMCP also differs from server-side Checkout MCP. Do not assume support for one means support for the other, or that this table proves any named agent has integrated them. Storefront tool limits.

A retailer's acceptance checklist

These are practical checks to run in your own systems, not claims that the agents above already pass them.

Common questions from retailers

Can an AI agent check out on a retailer's site?

Several documented routes exist. Link lists Muse, Instinct and Grok Bot as supporting agent payments through Link checkout. Meta documents purchases with a card saved in the merchant account. Copilot Checkout embeds checkout in the chat for supported products, with Stripe sending a Shared Payment Token to the seller. Shopify documents browser tools that read and update an active checkout and submit it after buyer confirmation. Documentation checked 9 October 2026; no hands-on purchase tests.

Who is the merchant of record when an AI agent pays?

On the Copilot Checkout route, Stripe sends a Shared Payment Token to the seller, who remains merchant of record. On the other documented routes the merchant fulfils the order. Approval, fraud checks and fulfilment terms differ per route, so confirm them in your own payment stack rather than assuming one model fits all seven agents.

Does Link support mean every agent order uses a new card?

No. Stripe describes two Muse routes: an existing Link payment method at businesses that accept Link, and a single-use virtual card scoped to an approved purchase elsewhere. Meta also documents purchases with a card saved in the merchant account. A blanket claim that every order uses a new virtual card would be wrong.

Do agent orders preserve accounts, loyalty and returns?

Not by default on the documented routes. Neither saved-card purchases nor embedded in-chat commerce guarantees account matching, loyalty points or returns reconciliation in your own store. Test those separately before treating agent orders like returning-customer orders.

What should a retailer check before supporting agent checkouts?

The acceptance checklist above spells out seven areas: product truth (variants, stock, price, delivery and return terms consistent across product pages and feeds), identity and loyalty (recognised account or guest), payment and fraud (unchanged fraud controls, duplicate-order handling), customer responsibility, merchant controls (onboarding, opt-out settings, fees in your provider account), safe backend actions, and measurement that separates observable agent sessions from guessed bot traffic. These are checks to run in your own systems, not claims that the agents already pass them.

What this comparison deliberately leaves out

We do not repeat unverified transaction-volume, valuation, market-share or partnership claims. We do not rank agents by purchase success, refund handling or retailer friendliness without comparable tests. Retailer-specific fees and contracts are not a universal price list. Where an official source describes a rollout rather than current global availability, the table says so.

Copilot Checkout is not Copilot Studio or Microsoft work agents. Dots is not ChatGPT Instant Checkout. Cue is not every feature in the general Manus product. Spark is not interchangeable with every Google Shopping checkout. This page keeps the seven entries from the original idea without merging different products.

How this page stays current

Each row has a last-verified date and primary-source links. We include this page in the regular site research cycle: check changed payment, access and approval documentation, then update affected rows after the evidence and visual gates pass. A full comparison review belongs in the fortnightly research audit. We do not refresh dates without rereading the relevant sources.

Announcements are evidence of what a company said on that date, not proof of rollout to every merchant. If sources conflict or stop answering a question, the row gets an explicit gap rather than an inferred answer. See our methodology and corrections policy.

Sources and further reading

The retailer-facing angle was suggested by Roger Dunn's 5 October comparison. Its prose, ratings and image table are not reproduced. All product facts above were checked against the linked company or payment-provider sources.

Related: Personal assistant agents, Privacy and approval checklist, Muse, Instinct, Dots, Cue.